Thanksgiving, Temptation, and the Question of Trust
Nobody will ask whether families should be trusted with their Thanksgiving money.
November 18, 2026
Thanksgiving is approaching. Across America, families are making lists, filling shopping carts, buying more food than they can possibly eat, selecting wine and beer, baking pies, and anticipating the day when most of us will eat too much. There will be second helpings, third helpings, another piece of pie, and another glass of wine. Some of us will spend money we should probably have saved. Some will wake up the next morning wondering why we ate so much.
Nobody will ask whether families should be trusted with their Thanksgiving money.
Nobody will suggest that the government should issue grocery vouchers instead of cash, require receipts for the turkey, or appoint someone to approve the purchase of pumpkin pie. We understand that adults make their own decisions, sometimes indulge themselves, and occasionally spend money unwisely. We accept that as part of being human.
Yet when someone proposes giving a low-income mother $400 a month to help raise her baby, a different question often emerges: What if she spends it on alcohol or cigarettes? What if she makes poor choices?
It is an old suspicion that research has repeatedly disproved.
In a 2017 study published in Economic Development and Cultural Change[1], economists David Evans and Anna Popova examined 19 studies of cash-transfer programs. They analyzed the effects of giving money directly to families and specifically investigated whether recipients increased spending on alcohol and tobacco. The results were striking: cash transfers actually produced an average reduction in expenditures like these .
In the overwhelming majority of studies, spending on alcohol and tobacco either remained unchanged or declined. A separate World Bank review[2] reached the same conclusion. Preconceptions that poor families squander cash assistance is not supported by evidence.
This does not mean that no one ever makes an unhealthy or irresponsible purchase. But it does tell us something important: giving families money does not irrevocably lead to its misuse.
Why, then, continue to question the judgment of mothers living in poverty?
Perhaps because we are accustomed to thinking of poverty as a failure of judgment rather than as a shortage of resources. We may assume that people who cannot afford to pay their bills might also be incapable of deciding how to spend money wisely.
At Family Health Project, we have chosen to begin with a different assumption. We provide first-time mothers with $400 every month for the first three years of their child's life. There are no conditions attached, no receipts to submit, and no spending restrictions.
We trust mothers to know what their families need. One of our mothers was diagnosed with cancer during her pregnancy. FHP’s financial assistance helped her obtain the healthcare she needed during an extraordinarily difficult period. Other mothers have used the payments for groceries, diapers, birthday celebrations, and the everyday expenses that come with raising a child. One mother described the relief of knowing that money would arrive every month as helping to alleviate her postpartum depression.
These are not stories about extraordinary financial decisions. They are stories about mothers doing what mothers everywhere do: trying to give their children a good beginning.
The distinction matters. Poverty does not eliminate a person's ability to make sound decisions. In fact, mothers living on very limited incomes make difficult financial calculations every day. They know which bill must be paid first, what the baby needs, and where a few hundred dollars can make the greatest difference.
The first three years of life are among the most consequential for a child's physical, emotional, and cognitive development. Chronic financial stress can undermine the environment in which healthy development takes place. So, a predictable monthly payment provides something beyond its purchasing power: stability, breathing room, and the ability to plan.
Cash does not solve every problem. But adding suspicion and bureaucracy to the lives of already struggling mothers solves no problems.
This Thanksgiving, as we enjoy the freedom to decide what goes on our tables, take a moment to remember the mothers who are simply trying to put food on theirs.
We trust ourselves to make our own choices. We can trust mothers to make theirs.
________________________________________________
[1] 1. Evans, David K., and Anna Popova (2017). Cash Transfers and Temptation Goods, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 65(2), 189–221.
[2] Evans and Popova (2014). World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 6886.

